Good update.
The first one is quit nice, the colors are good and looks fit. Lightning is ok, but could be better. And a nice picture, lol

The second one is the best in my opinion. Colors looks fit and effects are nice. Lightning is very well done.
The third one is nice. It's a bit different with the frame texture. Stars looks bad though, and text could be improved, think you should put the opacity up, and make it bigger.
The fourth one is the second best. Colours and lightning looks nice, lightning is a bit overdone near his eyes though. Font and effect looks good too.
The last one is okay, but it's too simple in my opinion. Add some effects, could be some color, or a texture of some sort. Lightning is very good.
If i were you i would go with the Pato one, think it's the best.